Celebrities

A Talent for Murder Review: Helen Mirren Thriller Has Style but Little Suspense

· 5 min read

A Talent for Murder is in theaters October 22.

A Talent for Murder has a promising setup: an ambitious literary agent, a notoriously difficult novelist, and a meeting where the prospect of murder hangs in the air. But director Anton Corbijn’s thriller keeps turning away from its own suspense. Its central device—a mystery being invented inside the film—offers a clever way to explore the characters, then leaves both stories short on urgency.

Adapted by playwright Joanna Murray-Smith from her stage play Switzerland, the film sends New York literary-agency employee Edward Ridgeway to Patricia Highsmith’s Swiss home. His assignment is to persuade the celebrated author to write another novel featuring Tom Ripley, her best-known creation. Edward needs a signed contract to keep his job. Highsmith wants no part of it.

Alden Ehrenreich plays Edward as an apparently guileless man whose persistence gets him an overnight stay with the reclusive writer. Helen Mirren’s Highsmith is prickly from the outset and firmly opposed to reviving Ripley, the suave sociopath who has long helped pay her bills. The assignment comes with a darker precedent, too: another employee sent to secure a book may have been killed. That threat gives Edward’s visit an edge, though the film is slow to turn it into real tension.

A thriller nested inside a pitch

Once Edward and Highsmith sit down to work out a story she might actually want to write, the film devotes much of its time to staging that imagined novel. Edward becomes its Ripley-like lead, a young man who charms his way into the life of a woman whose wealth could make him rich. Olivia Cooke plays Clementine Balfour, the woman Edward meets on the train to Switzerland and then reshapes into the fictional story’s romantic target.

The parallel between the two plots is clear enough: in each, a young man may be using charm to get close to someone who can give him what he wants. The problem is that the imagined story is presented as a narrated pitch, while the frame story leaves Edward and Highsmith largely discussing events rather than driving them. The result is a pair of plots that weaken each other. The novel-in-progress has no independent stakes, and the story in the Swiss house loses momentum whenever it gives way to the fantasy.

The film has “great gowns, beautiful gowns”; what it’s missing is surprise.

Strong performances, a muted payoff

Mirren and Ehrenreich make the sparring between author and agent enjoyable, and Ehrenreich handles the dual role with care as Edward and his fictional counterpart begin to blur. Cooke is appealing as Clementine, though the character gives her little room to stretch. The film’s craft makes a stronger impression: Robbie Ryan’s Swiss location photography is rich with color, while the costumes and production design give the movie a polished, inviting surface.

That visual elegance can’t supply the twists the story needs. Edward and Highsmith’s invented plot can contain murder and mayhem, but the audience is still watching two people in a room invent it. That distance saps the dread that makes a compact mystery work. Plays such as Anthony Shaffer’s Sleuth and Ira Levin’s Deathtrap build toward reversals that transform what came before. A Talent for Murder never lands a comparable turn, leaving its layered structure more mannered than suspenseful.

Stage roots show through

Without having seen the play, the film’s leisurely pace suggests an adaptation that holds tightly to its theatrical origins. Murray-Smith has written for film before, but her work is rooted in the stage, where a conversation can carry a different kind of energy than it does on screen. The material has plenty to work with: a famous author, a desperate agent and a story that might be concealing more than it reveals. Yet the film doesn’t reshape those ingredients into a thriller with enough forward drive.

There’s pleasure in watching Mirren and Ehrenreich test each other, and the film is consistently handsome. But atmosphere and performance can only take the mystery so far. A Talent for Murder has the pieces of a sharp chamber thriller; its nested plot keeps the danger at arm’s length.

Source: CarlosAMorales · www.ign.com