Celebrities

Wicker Reviews Praise Olivia Colman and Alexander Skarsgård’s Unusual Romance

· 5 min read

The appeal of Wicker rests on an unlikely pairing: Olivia Colman’s prickly Fisherwoman and Alexander Skarsgård’s tender, sentient wicker husband. Early reviews say their connection gives this romantic fantasy its emotional pull, even as the film’s 105-minute story sometimes stretches thin.

Directed by Alex Huston Fischer and Eleanor Wilson, the 2026 comedy adapts Ursula Wills-Jones’s 2008 short story “The Wicker Husband.” Reviews listed with the film give it a 94% Tomatometer score and a 93% Popcornmeter score. Elizabeth Debicki and Peter Dinklage also star.

Two performances make the strange premise work

Colman’s Fisherwoman is tough when others mock her, but critics say the performance also finds the hurt beneath that guarded manner. Geek Vibes Nation’s Liselotte Vanophem points to the contrast between her defiance and the vulnerability that surfaces in quieter scenes. The Times’ Kevin Maher argues Colman lifts the film beyond the limits of its medieval comedy setup.

Skarsgård has a different challenge: making a figure woven from wicker feel like a person rather than a visual gag. Reviewers praise the warmth and innocence he brings to the part. At Reeling Reviews, Laura Clifford notes that his eyes and tentative speech carry much of the character’s emotional expression; the role’s unlikely sex appeal is part of the joke and the romance.

Debicki’s performance as a jealous, cruel presence supplies some of the film’s darker comedy, according to Awards Radar’s Joey Magidson. Peter Dinklage fits the story’s heightened tone, Patrick Cavanaugh writes at The Wolfman Cometh, while MovieWeb’s Molly Freeman singles out Richard E. Grant’s brief appearance as the village doctor.

A love story with a mischievous edge

Critics describe the central relationship as tender, fragile and deliberately sensual. The comedy draws on the oddness of a human falling for a wicker figure, but reviews suggest the attraction is not just a running gag. It gives the film room to play with desire, marriage, jealousy and the divide between social outsiders and insiders.

That mix shapes the film’s bawdy humor. Inverse’s Lyvie Scott says the story is less interested in depicting sex than in showing how sexual frustration unsettles an entire village. Time Out’s Leonie Cooper leans into the absurdity of finding a wicker man desirable, while Reel Reviews’ Frank Wilkins praises the innuendo and the film’s observations about jealousy and marriage.

The tone has drawn comparisons to The Princess Bride, with Pajiba’s Jason Adams recasting its famous declaration as “As you wood.” Moviefone’s Don Kaye sees echoes of Edward Scissorhands in the story of an artificial being whose humanity stands out against the people around him. Other reviewers invoke Beauty and the Beast to describe Skarsgård’s handsome, regal presence.

Where the film loses momentum

The adaptation’s main hurdle is scale. Wills-Jones’s source story runs 14 pages, while Fischer and Wilson build it into a feature lasting 105 minutes. Blu-ray.com’s Brian Orndorf says the added world-building and supporting characters reveal the strain of expanding that compact premise.

Some critics find the result repetitive. Scene Now’s Wael Khairy says the plot circles familiar jokes without giving them enough fresh meaning, leaving the film short on emotional depth. Other reviews are more positive about its screenplay: Buttered Popcorn’s Carson Timar says it pairs comedy with ideas about gender and social change. The early response, then, points to a film whose charms are clear but whose pacing and writing don’t always sustain them.

Period craft brings the fable to life

The film’s visual and sound work earns praise even from critics who question the script. Reviewers cite Lol Crawley’s cinematography, Renato Cseh’s production design and costumes that evoke a storybook past. WETA Workshop’s practical effects and visual effects give Skarsgård’s woven character a face and presence; sound designer Andy Neil adds a soft creak that helps make the figure feel vulnerable as well as strange.

Wicker opens in theaters October 23. Get your tickets here.

Find Something Fresh! Discover What to Watch, Read Reviews, Leave Ratings and Build Watchlists. Download the Rotten Tomatoes App.

Source: Maggie Kwan · editorial.rottentomatoes.com