Movies

Best A24 Horror Movies Ranked by Tomatometer

· 5 min read

Best A24 Horror Movies, Ranked by Tomatometer


Latest update: A24’s 2026 horror releases Backrooms and Undertone have joined the list.


A24 made horror its calling card

A24’s horror reputation grew alongside the studio’s rise in the 2010s. Its approach stood apart from Blumhouse: where Blumhouse became known for tight budgets and movies built for broad audiences, A24 leaned into unsettling ideas, unusual forms, and scares that didn’t always follow familiar genre rules. The distinction matters. A24 helped make horror feel like a place for formal experimentation as well as a reliable source of thrills.

The studio’s breakout horror year was 2016. Robert Eggers’ The Witch brought carefully researched period horror, while Green Room turned a backwoods punk show into a brutal survival story. A24 also released the Best Picture Oscar winner Moonlight that year, showing how far the company’s ambitions stretched beyond horror. Its profile had already been rising through the decade, alongside peers such as Blumhouse and the broader wave of 2010s cinema.

Then Hereditary became A24’s highest-grossing film, a record it held until Everything Everywhere All At Once. It also launched Ari Aster’s feature filmmaking career; he followed it with the sun-drenched dread of 2019’s Midsommar. For the studio, critical attention and commercial reach could coexist, even when the films themselves remained strange and uncompromising.

Horror that asks more of its audience

“Elevated horror” became shorthand for films that built fear through mood, unease, and ideas rather than leaning chiefly on jump scares. It Follows and Blumhouse’s Get Out are prominent examples. The label has faded, but the shift it described is still visible: audiences were being asked to take horror seriously as filmmaking and as a way to examine social questions.

A24 has kept pushing in that direction through the 2020s. Rose Glass’ Saint Maud, Ti West’s X, Pearl, and MaXXXine, plus Talk To Me, show how varied that identity can be. Here’s the thing: the studio’s signature isn’t one recognizable kind of monster or scare. It’s a willingness to let filmmakers take familiar horror machinery somewhere less predictable.

The ranking below uses Tomatometer scores, which offer a useful snapshot of critics’ response. They don’t settle which film will work best for you; audience scores can diverge, and taste in horror is unusually personal. Still, the list makes a strong case that A24’s most durable contribution has been expanding what a horror film can look and feel like.

#1 Talk to Me
#2 X
#3 Pearl
#4 Saint Maud
#5 In Fabric
#6 The Witch
#7 The Lighthouse

Unsettling family secrets and survival horror

At No. 8, Hereditary (2018) has a 90% Tomatometer score and a 72% Popcornmeter score. Ari Aster’s film turns a family tragedy into something far more disturbing: after the Graham family matriarch dies, her daughter and grandchildren uncover frightening secrets about their ancestry. Toni Collette, Gabriel Byrne, Alex Wolff, and Ann Dowd star. The critics’ case is that its familiar setup gives way to horror that keeps its grip long after the credits. Hereditary At No. 9, Jeremy Saulnier’s Green Room (2015) also scores 90% with critics, alongside a 75% Popcornmeter rating. A punk band and a young woman face murderous white supremacists at a remote Oregon roadhouse. Anton Yelchin, Imogen Poots, Alia Shawkat, and Joe Cole lead the cast. The appeal here is blunt tension sharpened by intelligence and strong performances; the movie earns its genre thrills rather than coasting on them. Green Room

Horror built on what stays hidden

The gap between critics and audiences widens at No. 12. It Comes at Night (2017) has an 88% Tomatometer score but just 44% from audiences. Trey Edward Shults’s story traps two families in an uneasy shared home after a mysterious apocalypse leaves few survivors. Joel Edgerton, Christopher Abbott, Carmen Ejogo, and Riley Keough star. Its restraint is the point: the unseen threat does much of the work, though that approach clearly doesn’t satisfy everyone. It Comes at Night At No. 14, Lamb (2021) sits at 86% with critics and 58% with audiences. In rural Iceland, a childless couple makes a disturbing discovery in their sheep barn and soon faces the consequences of defying the will behind it. Noomi Rapace, Hilmir Snær Guðnason, Björn Hlynur Haraldsson, and Ingvar Eggert Sigurðsson anchor the film. Its strange premise and central performances give this one a markedly offbeat chill. Lamb

Recent entries and a sharp change of pace

At No. 10, Heretic (2024) earns 89% from critics and 76% from audiences. Scott Beck and Bryan Woods send two young missionaries to the wrong door, where they meet the diabolical Mr. Reed, played by Hugh Grant. Sophie Thatcher, Chloe East, and Topher Grace also star. Grant’s performance is the draw, while the film’s religious horror leans toward cerebral unease over sudden shocks. Heretic The 2025 entry at No. 11, Bring Her Back, has an 89% Tomatometer score and a 79% Popcornmeter score. A brother and sister discover a terrifying ritual in the secluded home of their new foster mother. Sally Hawkins, Billy Barratt, Sora Wong, and Jonah Wren Phillips star, with Danny and Michael Philippou directing. The critics’ consensus singles out Hawkins’s deranged turn as the source of the film’s most potent scares. Bring Her Back One forthcoming title appears at No. 13: Backrooms (2026), with 86% from critics and 70% from audiences. A strange doorway opens in a furniture showroom basement, setting up Kane Parsons’s feature debut. Chiwetel Ejiofor, Renate Reinsve, Mark Duplass, and Finn Bennett star. The premise draws on the internet’s familiar liminal spaces, and the early consensus describes the result as both mesmerizing and terrifying. Backrooms Then the list turns comic at No. 15. Bodies Bodies Bodies (2022) scores 85% with critics and 61% with audiences. A hurricane party at a remote family mansion goes sideways when a game among wealthy twenty-somethings takes a bad turn. Amandla Stenberg, Maria Bakalova, Myha’la Herrold, and Chase Sui Wonders star. Halina Reijn directs a whodunit whose sharp writing and casting seem to have won critics over more decisively than viewers. Bodies Bodies Bodies At No. 16, I Saw the TV Glow (2024) has an 85% Tomatometer score and a 49% Popcornmeter score. That split is a reminder that critical approval doesn’t always translate into broad audience enthusiasm. Tomatometer iconPopcornmeter icon

At #16, I Saw the TV Glow marks Jane Schoenbrun as a filmmaker whose striking visual choices serve an emotionally charged story. The available synopsis follows suburban teenager Owen after a classmate introduces him to a mysterious late-night show. View Full Synopsis Justice Smith, Brigette Lundy-Paine, Ian Foreman, and Lindsey Jordan star; Jane Schoenbrun directs.

Unsettling images, uneasy worlds

Under the Skin (#17, 2013) is the clearest case here for letting atmosphere do the talking. Scarlett Johansson plays an extraterrestrial who takes human form and drives through Scotland, luring men into her van. Its 84% Tomatometer score sits well above its 55% Popcornmeter score. That gap tracks with a film whose absorbing imagery and Johansson’s mesmerizing performance make for a haunting experience, even if its meaning can remain elusive. Jeremy McWilliams, Lynsey Taylor Mackay, and Dougie McConnell also star; Jonathan Glazer directs.

Under the Skin

Midsommar (#18, 2019) takes a more expansive route to dread. A young American couple whose relationship is failing travel to a Swedish midsummer celebration; the pastoral setting turns nightmarish. Florence Pugh, Jack Reynor, William Jackson Harper, and Will Poulter star. Ari Aster directs, alongside Fredrik Heinig, Pelle Nilsson, and Ben Rimmer. The film’s 83% Tomatometer rating and 65% Popcornmeter rating accompany a consensus that calls it ambitious, carefully made, and deeply unsettling—a strong case for Aster as a horror auteur. View Full Synopsis

Midsommar

At #19, High Life (2018) offers a colder, more difficult kind of science fiction. Monte and his infant daughter are the last survivors of a perilous mission near the solar system’s edge. Robert Pattinson, Juliette Binoche, André Benjamin, and Mia Goth star in Claire Denis’s film. Critics give it 83%, while its audience score is 42%—a sharp split that suggests its visually arresting, challenging approach won’t work for everyone. For viewers willing to sit with its uncertainties, that difficulty may be part of the reward. View Full Synopsis

High Life

The Hole in the Ground closes this stretch at #20 with a familiar fear: a parent’s suspicion that a child has come back changed. After Sarah’s young son vanishes into the woods, he returns looking the same, but his behavior shifts. Seána Kerslake, James Quinn Markey, James Cosmo, and Kati Outinen star; Lee Cronin, Hilary Davis, Tara Moross, and Tim Hegarty are credited as directors. The film scores 83% with critics and 48% with audiences. Its premise isn’t especially original, but the effective execution gives this horror story its bite. View Full Synopsis

The Hole in the Ground
Source: Alex Vo · editorial.rottentomatoes.com