Celebrities

Prince Edward Island Food Guide: Oysters, Mussels and the Island’s Best Lobster Roll

· 5 min read
Oysters on the half shell served on a pink napkin with horseradish, lemon wedge, and fork.
Raspberry Point oysters at Landmark Oyster House on Prince Edward Island. | Kate Heddings

Prince Edward Island makes a strong case for planning a trip around what’s on the plate. Within an island roughly 140 miles long, local oysters, potatoes, beef, dairy and other seafood shape a food culture that reflects its Mi’kmaq, Acadian, Irish, Scottish and other roots. My read: the best way to experience that variety is to pair Charlottetown’s walkable restaurants with drives to small harbors and coastal towns.

A white clapboard lighthouse with blue sky in the background.

My husband and I used Charlottetown as a base for a trip of just under three days. We rented a car, which made it possible to move from the capital to Victoria-by-the-Sea, Rustico Harbor and Covehead Wharf. The island’s red roads, fishing boats, lighthouses and beaches are part of the appeal; the meals make the short drives worthwhile.

We also made time for Green Gables Heritage Place, a personal priority because of my affection for L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables, and the PEI International Shellfish Festival. The festival brought together freshly shucked oysters and clams, buttered lobster rolls, mussels, cooking demonstrations, shucking contests and live entertainment. It’s an especially useful snapshot of the ingredients that define the island.

Wooden rowhouses, with pink, red, and white petunias in the foreground.

Charlottetown starts with cocktails and a late-night bar

Most of central Charlottetown is reachable on foot in about 20 minutes, so the first evening needed no car. At Slaymaker & Nichols, a gastropub and inn with the mood of a traditional supper club, I ordered a watermelon mule made with hibiscus-infused vodka and pickled watermelon. The drink was a good match for lobster dip with tomato and harissa, plus shrimp pil pil and asparagus. The building takes its name from a 19th-century circus that once performed on the site.

A pink cocktail is poured into a bathtub-shaped cup.

After a disappointing first attempt at a lobster roll, we went to Reddins, an intimate third-floor speakeasy decorated with vintage furniture and soundtracked by jazz. Bartender AB explained that the site had once been a pharmacy. During Prohibition, drugstores could dispense alcohol by prescription, which gave customers a way to get their “medicine.”

The bar’s Pink Canary was the standout: vodka, rose, lychee, citrus and rosé bubbles served in a miniature bathtub. It leans sweet, but the playful presentation suits the room. Reddins requires a password when you buzz from downstairs; the code is available online, or the neighboring hostess can help.

Day two: a hearty breakfast, oysters and PEI beef

Breakfast at Receiver Coffee

Rain pushed breakfast indoors at Receiver Coffee near Victoria Row. The local roaster’s strong coffee and Earl Grey cream tea were welcome starts, but the Ham Slam made the meal: a fluffy cheddar biscuit filled with a runny fried egg, Black Forest ham, Swiss cheese and Dijon mayonnaise. It’s substantial enough to carry you through a day that includes both a festival and a drive across the island.

Victoria-by-the-Sea: Landmark Oyster House and Island Chocolates

Victoria-by-the-Sea covers about half a square mile and has fewer than 200 residents, yet it’s home to a destination-worthy seafood stop. Landmark Oyster House occupies a former general store with green shingles and a steep roof. Our waiter recommended Raspberry Point oysters, medium in size with a balance of brine and sweetness. Freshly grated horseradish and lemon brought out their character.

Scallops on a hot dog bun, garnished with pickled red onions and chives, with a side of potato salad.

The scallop dog was a more indulgent order: sweet scallops with bacon jam, red pepper aioli and pickled shallots in a toasted bun. An eggy potato salad came alongside. After lunch, we walked past the lighthouse and stopped at Island Chocolates, a family-run shop and café. Its handcrafted bars and truffles often feature local ingredients; the haskap berry truffle paired the fruit’s blueberry-meets-raspberry flavor with a thick milk chocolate shell.

Once the weather cleared, we returned to the shellfish festival for more oysters and clams. The lobster rolls there kept the focus on the meat, with melted butter poured over generous servings from a large vat. It was a straightforward, satisfying expression of the island’s seafood abundance.

Dinner at North Shore Canteen

North Shore Canteen in French River came recommended by staff at Slaymaker and Nichols, and the changing menu made the trip a good way to see what local kitchens were working with. That night’s choices included halibut, striped bass, shellfish, beef and potatoes. The beef tartare arrived in a generous portion, seasoned with capers and roasted garlic and finished with freshly grated Parmesan. Covered Bridge potato chips made a crisp, salty counterpoint.

We followed it with hanger steak, served with chimichurri and black garlic. The cut showed off PEI beef without overcomplicating it. Dessert was parsnip cake with caramel sauce, a confident finish to a meal built around local ingredients.

Day three: Green Gables, mussels and the lobster roll worth the drive

Green Gables Heritage Place delivered the literary detour I’d planned: the house, the Haunted Wood and Lover’s Lane, plus nonalcoholic raspberry cordial. The visit left us hungry, and the final day became an intentional two-lunch crawl.

First lunch at Blue Mussel Café

Pot of mussels with lemon wedge, small baguette, and metal cup of melted butter perched on top.

Blue Mussel Café sits near the water at Rustico Harbor, in a bright, welcoming space that draws diners for its namesake shellfish. The mussels arrive piled high in a stainless steel bowl, plump and fresh. Choose rosemary and lemon or beer and wine; both preparations worked, though the rosemary added a fragrant lift. A small ramekin of melted butter comes on the side. The seafood chowder, made with haddock, salmon, scallops, mussels and PEI potatoes, looked popular and comes with a large biscuit.

Second lunch at Richard’s Fresh Seafood

Richard’s Fresh Seafood at Covehead Wharf delivered the lobster roll I’d been looking for. One of the island’s longest-running fish shacks, it offers a deck overlooking fishing boats as well as easy access to the beach beneath the lighthouse. The roll is packed with sweet lobster in both chunky and fine pieces, dressed with lemon and chive mayonnaise and small bits of onion, then tucked into a buttery toasted bun.

Crunchy coleslaw, crisp fries and a cup of ketchup complete the plate. It’s an abundant, well-balanced version of a familiar island staple, and the meal that best captured why a food-focused drive around PEI pays off.

Lobster roll, thick cut fries, and a cup of coleslaw served on newspaper.

Dinner at Rustico Cannery

Rustico Cannery, which opened that spring, made a relaxed final dinner stop near North Rustico Harbor. Large windows and a broad deck take in sunset views. We ordered crisp romaine hearts dressed with creamy, spicy charred jalapeño, with lardons, Parmesan and sourdough crunchies. My husband’s panko-crusted, pan-fried haddock came with pickled beet remoulade, jalapeño relish, confit potatoes and coleslaw.

Make room for Cows Creamery

We made several visits to Cows Creamery, whose ice cream uses milk from small local dairy farms and is sold at locations around PEI. Coffee Cowrunch combines English toffee and Oreo; Cownadian Maple layers maple ice cream, maple swirl and maple cookie pieces; Messie Bessie mixes chocolate ice cream with Oreo, toffee and Cow Chips. Those thick, ruffled potato chips coated in milk or dark chocolate are also sold by the bag around the island.

That range is what makes PEI easy to eat your way across: seafood pulled from nearby waters, potatoes and beef from the island, dairy turned into ice cream, and small towns where a meal can lead straight to a lighthouse or beach. Many restaurants operate seasonally, so check opening dates before building a cooler-weather itinerary.

Source: Kate Heddings · www.eater.com