TV Shows

James Bond Casting Backlash: How the Press Reacted to Every 007

· 5 min read

Every new James Bond arrives with a built in comparison: audiences measure the actor against the 007 who came before. Newspaper coverage of the casting announcements shows that the debate is older than online fandom. Sean Connery was dismissed as an unknown; George Lazenby’s lack of acting experience made him an easy target; and Daniel Craig faced a sustained campaign against his casting. The response depended as much on an actor’s public profile as on his predecessor’s legacy.

A review of newspaper coverage from Connery through Craig offers a useful reminder as speculation builds around the next Bond. Reports from each era reveal how quickly uncertainty can harden into a verdict—and how poorly early reactions can predict a performance’s place in the series.

November 3 marks the 65th anniversary of Connery’s casting announcement. The skepticism was already there in 1961: “Sean Connery, chosen to play Bond on the screen, had better be good.” The line sounds familiar because the cycle of fan scrutiny has never really stopped. Before Bond reached theaters, Ian Fleming’s novels were bestsellers and even President John F. Kennedy had made his enthusiasm for 007 known. Yet when Scottish actor Connery won the lead in Dr. No, many readers of the casting news still had to ask who he was.

Connery’s obscurity at the moment of casting is striking in hindsight. He became a global star through the franchise and later topped nearly every “best Bond” poll, until Daniel Craig began to challenge that consensus. One reporter’s early jab reads now like a vintage fan post: a sharp, dismissive judgment made before Connery had a chance to define the role.

Experience mattered more than familiarity

George Lazenby faced a different problem when his casting was announced on October 7, 1968. Connery had been unknown to the public, but he was an actor. Lazenby, an Australian male model known for advertisements, had no acting career to point to. Coverage stressed that inexperience as he took on the difficult task of succeeding Connery.

He played Bond once, in On Her Majesty’s Secret Service. EON Productions later brought Connery back for Diamonds Are Forever. Lazenby’s brief run, and the reputation for ego and inexperience that followed him, became part of the story retold in the 2017 docudrama Becoming Bond. The headlines below show that the questions about his credentials began before audiences saw him in the role.

Roger Moore had the reverse advantage. By the time he was announced as the third Bond on August 1, 1972, audiences knew him from The Saint, The Persuaders and Maverick. He was the best-known actor to take the part so far, and press coverage was largely favorable. Still, some headlines reduced him to a “TV Actor,” a label that reflected the period’s divide between television and film careers.

That distinction has since faded. Moore’s familiarity with television made him an obvious choice to many readers, even as the label itself carried a dismissive edge. His casting illustrates how an actor’s existing screen persona can help audiences accept a new Bond, while also shaping expectations for what that Bond should be.

Following a long-running Bond

Timothy Dalton’s appointment, announced August 6, 1986, revived a familiar question in a new form: could a Shakespearean actor convincingly play 007? Dalton, a Welsh actor, had been considered for Bond as far back as Live and Let Die. By the time he accepted, he was stepping into a role Moore had held for 12 years, ending with 1985’s A View to a Kill.

Dalton wasn’t the producers’ first choice for that moment. Pierce Brosnan was expected to star in The Living Daylights, but NBC wouldn’t release him from his Remington Steele contract. The press’s questions about Dalton also carried a sense of loss: some columnists mourned the end of Moore’s tenure even before the new Bond had established himself.

Dalton’s version was serious and closer to Ian Fleming’s literary character than Moore’s lighter, more playful portrayal. He made two Bond films, both of which drew a mixed response. But the character’s harder edge helped set a direction Craig would later take further. Dalton’s casting coverage, then, captures more than a handover between actors: it records an argument about whether Bond should be an escapist showman or a more grounded spy.

Pierce Brosnan finally became Bond after the franchise’s five-year pause. He was announced on June 8, 1994, following a dispute over screen rights that had kept production dormant from 1989. His casting came with a built-in audience: five seasons as the suave lead of Remington Steele had made him a familiar presence, often in a tuxedo and close to the Bond image.

For GoldenEye, Brosnan described himself as “older” and “wiser” and said he didn’t want his Bond to be as “politically correct” as Dalton’s. That comment framed the casting as both a return to a recognizable type and a shift in characterization. Unlike Connery or Lazenby, Brosnan didn’t need to persuade the public that he could look the part. The question was what kind of Bond he would choose to play.

Craig faced the loudest rejection

Daniel Craig’s casting, announced October 14, 2005, produced the sharpest backlash in this group. The initial headlines fixated on his blond hair, often turning “James Bond” into “James Blond.” Some tabloids quickly recast the joke as “James Bland,” while a dedicated site, CraigNotBond.com, formed to oppose his casting and still exists after Craig’s exit from the series with No Time to Die.

The response recalled the furor around Michael Keaton as Batman, with Tom Cruise as Lestat another comparison. Craig’s critics had a clear visual objection, but the volume of the reaction also reflected a deeper resistance to changing a role with a well-established image. His English background and physical appearance became proxies for a larger question: would this Bond feel like Bond?

Craig answered the doubts with his 2006 debut in Casino Royale. His performance gave Bond a wounded humanity that distinguished it from earlier interpretations, and he went on to lead the franchise for 15 years. The “James Bland” headlines now look less like a reliable forecast than a record of how confidently audiences can reject a casting before they’ve seen it work.

That pattern is relevant as attention turns to the next film, James Bond 26. Names in circulation include Callum Turner, Jack Lowden and Josh O’Connor, alongside frequent speculation about Jacob Elordi. As with every previous transition, each name carries assumptions about experience, image and the kind of Bond the franchise should become. Newspaper archives show that the argument starts well before an actor’s first scene. The performance, not the first headline, is what eventually settles it.

Source: Jim Vejvoda · www.ign.com