Celebrities

Seven Thanksgiving Sides Worth Crowding Onto the Table

· 5 min read

Mashed potatoes and stuffing get everyone to the table, but the sides are where the cooking gets interesting. They're the place to test a new idea, and they're also the place to fix the imbalance that a plate of butter, gravy, and starch creates. A bright, crunchy salad or a bubbling baked pasta can do more for the meal than another tray of the same old classics.

Here are seven recipes our editors have cooked, argued about, and decided deserve a spot on the holiday table.

a picture of a baking dish full of stuffing
We can all agree on one thing at Thanksgiving: The sides are the best part of the spread | Getty Images

Stuffing built on store-bought cornbread

Every year, Lesley Suter and her sister hold a stuffing showdown. Her sister makes a mushroom and sage version, and Suter makes a sausage cornbread stuffing with plenty of fennel, adapted from an old Gourmet recipe. The part that sets it apart is the bread. She buys full loaves of Whole Foods' signature cornbread, cubes them, and dries them in a low oven around 200 degrees for a few hours.

Why the store-bought loaves? Suter isn't entirely sure, but she has a theory. The bread is dense, a little stale before it ever reaches the oven, and consistent enough to dry out evenly. Its flavor also balances the fennel without pushing the dish toward sweetness. That's a lot of credit for a grocery-aisle loaf, and it's earned. Try the sausage fennel stuffing if you want a dressing that holds up through seconds.

Caramelized cabbage that doesn't read as a side

Nat Belkov, deputy brand director, keeps coming back to caramelized cabbage with bacon, miso, and mustard from Jesse Jenkins at BBC Food. Cabbage and bacon is a familiar pairing, but the miso and Dijon swirled into the reduction push it somewhere less predictable. Belkov points to the varied textures, the sharp acidity, and a quiet sweetness that makes the dish feel like a deliberate choice rather than filler.

The dish also comes with a bonus. Jenkins's cooking videos are so calm that Belkov compares them to food ASMR, and he suggests watching a few before the in-laws arrive.

Salads that cut through the richness

Nobody asks for a salad at Thanksgiving, but the heavy plates make one feel necessary by the second helping. Bettina Makalintal's pick is Matthew Accarino's fennel-and-citrus salad with mint from Food & Wine. Citrus brightens the dish and works well alongside cranberry sauce. The fennel's faint licorice note stands apart from the savory spread, and it echoes the celery in other dishes without repeating it.

Makalintal admits that more elaborate versions exist and sound delicious, but the pared-down one is easier to make on a day when the oven is already full. It's usually the last thing she makes before everyone sits down. She often doesn't announce it, and that's part of the appeal. It looks like an afterthought, then turns out to be the dish people remember.

For a heartier option, Dianne de Guzman recommends Tauba Auerbach's shredded Brussels sprouts salad with lemony almonds and shaved apple, from Julia Sherman's book Salad for President. Thinly shaved sprouts form the base, and toasted almonds marinated in lemon add crunch. The dressing combines sherry and cider vinegars, which sharpen the sweetness of the apple. If you have time, make the pickled mustard seeds. They add a layer of flavor that's easy to miss if you skip them.

Green beans that aren't steamed

Sarah Dyer's crispy garlic green beans start with a plea that Francky Knapp, staff writer, fully endorses: skip the steamed beans. They aren't offensive, but they can taste ghostly and one-note next to the sweet potatoes and beige classics. This version uses high-heat oil, plenty of garlic, and a handful of ice cubes to help the beans blister and crisp. The result is a garlicky char that wakes up the whole table.

Sweet potato casserole with a graham cracker streusel

Nicole Fellah has taken on the sweet potato role at her family's large outdoor potluck. Her version follows the familiar blueprint: slow-roasted sweet potatoes for deeper flavor, a brightening note from orange juice or cinnamon applesauce, a pecan-and-brown-sugar crumble, and blistered marshmallows on top. Recently, she changed things up with Epicurious's s'mores-inspired take. Maple syrup and unsweetened cocoa powder add earthiness to the filling, and crushed graham crackers give the topping extra crunch. Graham crackers are available gluten-free, which keeps the recipe welcoming for a crowd.

The flavor is close enough to the original that relatives won't feel cheated. That's the point. It's a crowd-pleaser with a small, deliberate tweak.

The Cheese Thing

Mitchell Davis named the dish on his blog, Cook and Eat Better, and it spread from there. Bon Appétit helped bring it to a wider audience in 2018, when it surfaced more broadly on the internet. It looks like a loose, wonky baked ziti. Cubes of cheese melt into the ridges of penne and mix with a simple, sweet, buttery tomato sauce. Hilary Pollack, deputy editor, finishes hers with salt, cracked pepper, and a generous shower of fluffy Pecorino, sometimes with extra cheese baked onto the top.

Pollack would call it a side, since it's easy to scale for a potluck or buffet. But she's quick to add that it could easily be a main on a cold night for two, four, or however many people fit on the couch. That flexibility is what makes it worth planning around. If you're building a menu that needs one dish to disappear before anything else, this is the candidate.

Take one side this year and make it the one that breaks the pattern. A salad, a green vegetable with some char, or a baked pasta can change the whole table, and it doesn't require rebuilding the rest of the menu. Start with the dish you'd miss most if it didn't show up.

Source: Eater Staff · www.eater.com