Celebrities

Eight Staff-Tested Pies Worth Baking This Holiday Season

· 5 min read

Pie doesn't need a holiday excuse, but the season makes it easier to justify heating up the oven. These eight picks from Eater's staff range from a savory tart that has become a yearly habit to a citrus pie with a dubious origin story. Together they cover savory, fruit, wobbly custard, and no-bake shortcuts for nights when nobody wants to fuss over a crust.

Eater staff pie recipes

Savory options that break up the dessert table

Every holiday table has a pumpkin pie and a pecan pie, so a savory option earns its spot by being different. That's the appeal of the Caramelized Onion & Butternut Squash Tart from Food52. Deputy director of audience development Terri Ciccone keeps coming back to it every fall, calling it a strong choice for Friendsgiving, Thanksgiving, or any autumn get-together. What sells it is how it leans on seasonal produce while standing apart from the sweet pies that dominate the sideboard. When she wants something heartier, she adds crumbled sausage.

Sweet Potato-Miso Pie With Chocolate-Sesame Crust

Here's the thing about this Bon Appétit recipe from Josh Walker and Duolan Li: it's built for people who find most desserts too sugary. The sweetness comes mostly from the sweet potatoes themselves, with brown sugar playing a supporting role. The crust is the real departure. It's made from ground black sesame seeds and crushed chocolate wafer cookies, which means you skip the cold butter and the careful lamination that flaky fruit-pie crusts demand. Deputy editor Rebecca Roland, who chose it for the Eater LA and Eater Southwest sites, points out that the crust is far less hands-on than the usual version.

Custards that wobble

Buttermilk Pie

Buttermilk pie isn't a dessert most people outside the American South have grown up with, and that's part of why Allrecipes' Tracy Mulder found it so compelling. She first ran into it through a Twitter thread about regional pies, then tested the first recipe that surfaced in a Google search. She's been making that same recipe ever since, and she says it has been reliably easy and perfect every time. The filling is smooth and velvety, with a little nutmeg and a hint of lemon. Audience editor Kat Thompson compares it to dan tat and Chinese egg tarts but argues it's far less fussy. You can make your own crust, but a store-bought one works fine, because the wobbly buttermilk custard is the star.

Chess Pie

Chess pie is simple enough that the story behind its name gets as much attention as the recipe. Allrecipes' T Knecht and their mom like to tell a tale, probably invented, about a diner server asked what flavor the custard was. Her answer, "It's just pie," supposedly came out in a Southern accent that sounded like "chess pie." The filling itself is built on evaporated milk, set with cornmeal. Knecht's mom has started adding edible lavender oil, which is now the family's favorite way to bake it. Social media manager Emily Venezky's household has also stirred in a spoonful or two of a spiced hot chocolate mix to make a chocolate version with some heat. Even plain, though, Venezky says it's a reliable crowd-pleaser.

Buttery, sticky, and no-bake

Butterscotch Pie

Deb Perelman's butterscotch pie from Smitten Kitchen earns an immediate comparison to one of New York's best-known desserts. Staff writer Francky Knapp says the first thing that comes to mind is "We have Milk Bar at home, honey." The Milk Bar pie, once given a salacious name that the bakery has since retired, is known now as the Milk Bar Pie. Knapp says this version delivers the same gooey, buttery richness and a satisfyingly sticky texture. It's a pie for anyone who would happily skip the main course and eat caramelized graham cracker crust and custard for dessert.

No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Crazy for Crust's Dorothy Kern respects elaborate pies with lattice tops, but her own go-to is far humbler. Her no-bake chocolate peanut butter pie is a five-ish-ingredient, semi-homemade creation built on Cool Whip, and she's been making it since high school. Deputy editor Hilary Pollack, who calls herself a bit of a bougie eater, still rates it highly. She says it's sweet, salty, creamy, and somehow both light and decadent at once. It gets rave reviews at dinner parties, holiday gatherings, and potlucks. For a true '90s touch, she recommends an Oreo crust and Skippy peanut butter, which she calls forever crowd-pleasers.

Citrus and chocolate for the finale

Atlantic Beach Pie

If you're tired after a heavy meal, this one cuts through the richness. Southern Living's Anna Theoktisto describes it as a zingy citrus pie that sits somewhere between a lemon pie and an icebox pudding. Deputy brand director Nat Belkov says it delivers exactly the bright acidity they crave after a marathon of rich food, and that the pie's saltine crust, zippy custard, and whipped cream make it hard to stop at one slice. The pie reportedly started at a North Carolina seafood restaurant, where it served as a playful way around an old wives' tale that eating dessert after seafood could be dangerous. Whatever you make of the lore, it's a good palate reset.

Chocolate Caramel Tart

Claudia Fleming's recipe, adapted by Amanda Hesser for the New York Times, is the one for people who don't love pie crust. Senior reporter Bettina Makalintal says she isn't really a pie person, since flaky crust stresses her out, but a tart only asks her to press dough into a pan. Her mom made this one often when she was growing up. It layers dark chocolate ganache over a caramel filling that gets extra depth from salt and crème fraîche, then finishes with a little more flaky salt on top. Makalintal's read is that it tastes like a more sophisticated Twix bar. She also once tried to win over an ex with it, and when he called it "just okay," she took that as the final sign they weren't a match. Her verdict on the tart stands regardless.

Where to start

If you're cooking for a crowd with mixed tastes, my read is to pair one savory dish with one no-bake pie. The savory option handles guests who skip dessert, and the no-bake pie handles the oven-space problem that always shows up around the holidays. Buttermilk and chess are the safest bets for traditionalists, while the chocolate caramel tart and butterscotch pie give the dessert table a richer edge. Pick the one that matches your kitchen's bottlenecks, and you'll have a crust-free, low-stress win.

Source: Eater Staff · www.eater.com