Celebrities

Eater Editors' Potluck Picks for Dishes That Travel Well and Win the Table

· 5 min read
Eater Staff Potluck Recipes
Consider this your cheat sheet for next time you’re asked to bring something tasty to the party | Eater Staff

A good potluck runs on a particular kind of generosity. Everyone brings one piece of the meal, and the table ends up richer than any single kitchen could manage. That's the appeal of the format, and it's also why the dishes that work best are the ones that survive a car ride, sit happily at room temperature, and don't need a full kitchen when they arrive.

Hosts have one job the guests don't: keeping the spread balanced. Assign or at least track whether people are bringing sweet or savory dishes, or you'll end up with a smorgasbord of, say, 12 onion dips. I'd happily eat all 12, but nobody else at the party will thank you. Once the categories are sorted, the holiday potluck gets looser and more fun. It rewards travel-friendly feuilletés, pillowy focaccia, and vegetarian options that don't feel like an afterthought. Here are the dishes the Eater editors keep coming back to.

Savory Dishes That Carry the Table

Start with the feuilleté, because it's essentially a sandwich that learned some manners. Thin layers of ham and Swiss are brushed with Dijon and finished with a heavy cream-and-egg wash that gives the pastry a glossy sheen. If you have time, visit a cheese counter and ask what the mongers are excited about this season. If you don't, a good pre-sliced Swiss from the grocery store does the job. Staff writer Francky Knapp favors Sargento's baby Swiss for its mild, nutty flavor and creamy texture. The real advantage is portability. Cut it into a million tiny squares for a crowded party, or into a handful of larger ones for a smaller gathering, and it holds up either way.

Mac and cheese is a bigger commitment. Justine Doiron's version, a four-cheese bechamel topped with garlic and sage breadcrumbs, is a project dish, and that's the point. It suits a competitive Friendsgiving or a cold-weather potluck full of serious home cooks, where somebody will notice the effort. Don't skip the fried breadcrumb topping, which is the part that makes the dish feel finished. That said, the sauce works on its own. Plenty of cooks have adjusted the recipe for picky eaters by leaving out the herbs and garlic topping and serving the bechamel plain. Emily Venezky, who manages the social media side of the newsroom, makes the case for that flexibility without losing the original.

The dirty martini dip is the one I'd bring if I wanted to win the room quickly. Dirty martinis have never been dirtier, and the briny, olive-y profile has spread into all sorts of snacks. Think of it as the cocktail's flavor translated into a format that can be replicated in other edible forms, including dirty martini deviled eggs. Hilary Pollack's take is a classic cream-cheese party dip with much bigger flavor. Her pick for dipping is ridged chips, since they hold up under a thick spread. She serves it every year at her holiday party, and it's the kind of dish that disappears before the host has a chance to refill the bowl.

Bread That Doesn't Ask Much of You

I'm not a baker by temperament. I don't have the patience for fussy presentation or exact measurements, and without much of a sweet tooth, I've never had a reason to change. Bread is the exception. Focaccia is forgiving, it feeds a crowd, and it looks generous even when it's simple. Most people will reach for a dependable standby recipe, and that's a fine instinct. When the occasion calls for something more festive, a few variations are worth knowing.

Deb Perelman's focaccia onion board has a bagel-like personality that suits a brunch spread especially well. For something with more bite, Shilpa Uskokovic's cacio e pepe focaccia at Bon Appétit adds pepper and cheese to a standard dough, which gives it character without changing the basic method. If you enjoy a bit of fussiness, search for "decorative focaccia" and you'll find people arranging tomatoes, rosemary, and onion slices into flowers across the top. It's a showpiece, and it's the rare potluck contribution that gets photographed before anyone touches it. Missy Frederick, editorial director for dining, sums up the appeal: bread is the one place where a little extra effort reliably pays off.

Pie Built for the Road

Yotam Ottolenghi's curried cauliflower and cheese filo pie is the dish I'd point to if you want one recipe that does almost everything right. Bettina Makalintal got hooked on phyllo pies after a friend noticed she kept bringing one to gatherings. The reasons are practical. A pie can travel still in its springform, which gives it structure on the drive. You can make the fillings ahead and assemble on the day. And when you arrive, you can ask the host to pop it in the oven for a few minutes, usually making use of whatever warmth is already in there.

The base recipe comes from Ottolenghi's Shelf Love. Cauliflower sits in a thick cheese sauce, which makes it a natural fit for colder months when people want something hearty. The format is flexible. Makalintal has swapped in mushrooms or beans, added caramelized onions or leeks, and played with Gruyère and greens. For guests who are vegan or lactose intolerant, she makes the pie dairy-free, and she notes that store-bought phyllo is generally vegan, which simplifies things. In warmer weather, or when she'd rather bring a skillet than a loaded springform, she turns to a spanakopita-style pie from Hetty McKinnon. Either way, the format gives vegetarian guests a dish that's substantial rather than an afterthought.

What Makes a Potluck Dish Worth Bringing

Across these picks, the pattern is clear. The best potluck dishes do their hardest work before the party starts. They hold their texture in a bag or a casserole dish, they don't need the host's oven at a critical moment, and they make the table look thoughtful. A feuilleté can be cut into any size. A pie can be pre-assembled. Focaccia can be dressed up or kept plain. Even the dirty martini dip, which asks almost nothing of you beyond a bowl and some sturdy chips, gets the room talking.

So the next time the group chat asks who's bringing what, skip the default bag of chips and choose something that travels, reheats with minimal fuss, and gives the vegetarians something to eat. My read is that the hosts who plan their menus this way will spend less time managing logistics and more time with the people at the table. That's the real point of the potluck, and the food should make that easier.

Source: Francky Knapp · www.eater.com